Back to Cookbook

Screening Rubric Builder

Consistent screening across recruiters and hiring managers

Builds a weighted, skills-first rubric for application review and early screens. Reduces inconsistency and makes handoffs faster.

CommunityWork4 min

PROMPT

Create a skill called "Screening Rubric Builder". Inputs: - Job description - Team context (what problems this hire solves) - Seniority level Output: 1) 6–10 evaluation criteria with weights (total 100) 2) Evidence examples for each criterion (what "strong" looks like) 3) Red flags and common false positives 4) Minimum bar rules (automatic reject vs manual review) 5) Interview mapping: which criteria get tested in which stage

How It Works

Paste the JD and team context. The skill builds a weighted rubric with

evidence examples and red-flag guidance.

What You Get

  • 6–10 evaluation criteria with weights (totaling 100)
  • Evidence examples for each (what "strong" looks like)
  • Red flags and common false positives
  • Minimum bar rules (auto-reject vs manual review)
  • Interview mapping (which criteria get tested in which stage)

Setup Steps

  1. Paste the job description
  2. Add team context (what problems this hire solves)
  3. Specify seniority level
  4. Share the rubric with all reviewers before screening begins

Tips

  • Calibrate with the hiring manager on 3–5 sample resumes before going live
  • Weights force prioritization — if everything is equal, nothing is
  • The false-positive guidance prevents "looks good on paper" mistakes
  • Pair with the Anchored Scorecard Builder for interview-stage scoring
Tags:#recruiting#screening#scorecards#consistency